Washington State University

Ask Dr. Universe

So many beetles, so much time!

January 6th, 2012

Dear Dr. Universe,
How is it that every animal is different?
Marisa
Valley Village, California

Entomologist Rich Zack with some of the insects in WSU's collection. Photo Robert Hubner

Entomologist Rich Zack with some of the insects in WSU's collection. Photo Robert Hubner

The fill-in-the-blank answer is “evolution.”

But if you were the type to be satisfied with fill-in-the-blank answers, you wouldn’t have asked this kind of question. So I went to talk again with Rich Zack, who runs the entomology museum here at Washington State University.

In this museum are approximately 1,250,000 dead insects representing about 50,000 species. (A species is a group of organisms with many things in common, including the ability to interbreed.) Most of these species live in the Pacific Northwest and are a fraction of the species that exist worldwide.

Biologist E.O. Wilson of Harvard has estimated that scientists have named 6,300 species of reptiles, 9,040 species of birds and 4,000 species of mammals. The total number of vertebrates (animals with backbones) they have described is around 42,580. In contrast, about one million species of insects have been identified, and some scientists think that there may be anywhere from 8 million to 30 million species of insects out there waiting to be named!

How can this be? How can there possibly be so many kinds of insects? And WHY?

Niches are one reason, says Professor Zack. A niche is an insect’s role in its community. The way an insect finds its niche is through adaptation and natural selection. As their surroundings change, insects best suited to this change survive. They are “naturally selected” to pass on that species’ genes.

A related reason there are so many insect species is they adapt by specializing. Let’s take beetles, for example.

Professor Zack says that over a third of all insect species are beetles, around 400,000 of them. And remember, that’s just the ones that have been identified. Groups, or “populations,” of species can become different for various reasons. Maybe they get separated from the others. Maybe their environment or food supply changes.

Let’s imagine, way back, that one species of beetle liked brontosaurus dung. They were perfectly happy to eat brontosaurus dung for the rest of time. Brontosaurus dung was their world!

But then, brontosauri started disappearing. Maybe a few of these beetles got hungry enough to start sampling a little dung from another plant-eating dinosaur. And maybe some of these beetles were actually able to digest this new dung without getting fatal heartburn.

One thing that makes natural selection work is that EVERY INDIVIDUAL is different. With that in mind, maybe some of the individuals able to digest the new dung were able to pass this ability to their children. And maybe some of their buddies across the swamp developed a taste for yet another variety of dinosaur dung. Not only were they able to get by on it, they even liked it!

As time passed, whatever made these different beetles able to digest different kinds of dungs got passed along to their offspring, so that they all became a new species—once they got so different they could no longer interbreed.

Now let your imagination run for a while. Think of variations on this situation over and over through time, as different populations adapted to different conditions as the environment changed.

Admittedly, insects are small, and we are big. Insects and larger mammals live and evolve at much different scales, of both time and space. Insects can pass through their whole life cycles in weeks, rather than decades, as we do. That means, says Professor Zack, that insects tend to take advantage of dividing up their habitat and becoming specialized, both because they’re smaller and because they can evolve more quickly.

But what about us? Why are humans different from monkeys and elephants and cats? Even though it takes longer for us to change, it’s basically the same idea. Over time we have adapted to the environment we live in. In the process, a BUNCH of different versions of us have come to share this world.

More than just a pretty bug!

January 6th, 2012

Dear Dr. Universe,
What are butterflies good for?
David Steury
Potlatch, Idaho

Fender’s blue butterflies

Fender’s blue butterflies. Read more in Washington State Magazine.

It just so happens that Robert Michael Pyle was here at Washington State University the other week to talk about butterflies. Mr. Pyle is a lepidopterist, which means he studies butterflies. He is the author of many books about nature and butterflies, including The Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Butterflies. He recently wrote a book called Chasing Monarchs, about following Monarch butterflies on their migration from British Columbia to the Mexican border!

So what are butterflies GOOD for? Humans tend to think of things as either good or bad (for humans!), and the same goes for insects. Insects are either pests or “beneficial,” which basically means “good to humans.” Well, that’s only part of the story, says Mr. Pyle.

Most insects are neither “good” nor “bad.” They’ve probably never seen a human and could care less about people. But they all perform some role in nature.

And this certainly includes butterflies.

A big job that butterflies do is pollinate plants so that plants can produce seeds and fruit. Many plants need help getting pollen from the flower’s male stamen to the ovules, either from their own flowers or from other plants of the same species. Ovules are like plant eggs, from which the seeds grow.

Many insects—including wasps, beetles, bees and flies—pollinate plants when they search for flower nectar for food. The pollen from one flower sticks to the head or legs of the insect and then falls off in another flower.

Butterflies are great pollinators, says Mr. Pyle. Their proboscis, a long feeding tube, reaches way down into the flower to suck nectar, and their heads get pollen all over them.

Butterflies are also food to many birds. They are particularly tasty when they are still caterpillars. Moth and butterfly larvae are a major food group for warblers and many other songbirds.

Butterflies, like other insects, can change plants through adaptation or evolution. Butterflies, particularly their larvae (the caterpillars), and other insects eat plants. These plants don’t always just stand there and take it. They develop defenses. One way is to produce substances that are either poisonous or taste bad to the insect.

However, many of these substances actually taste good to humans! Plants that have developed defenses against insects (and resulting good tastes to humans) include onions, cilantro, basil, cabbage and peppers.

Butterflies also let us know how the rest of nature is doing where they live. If their home is healthy, then they are usually healthy also. If their home is not healthy, then neither are they. Other animals besides butterflies are also thought of as “indicator species.” But the nice thing about butterflies, says Mr. Pyle, is that they are so visible.

If a place has a lot of butterflies, which then become fewer or disappear altogether, then that’s a pretty good sign that place has problems. Maybe too many chemicals are being used to kill other insects. Or maybe too many humans have moved in and destroyed the butterfly’s habitat. If that’s the case, the habitat has also disappeared for a lot of other animals and plants.

And when this happens, we have lost something very special. Mr. Pyle says butterflies are especially GOOD for their beauty. Imagine, he says, a world without butterflies. “I think the world would be a much poorer and sadder place without the brilliance and excitement and sheer pleasure that the sight of a butterfly brings.” I agree.

Thanks for a great question!

Why don’t you ever see dead birds in the forest?

September 22nd, 2011

[+] Click on the comic below to view full-size.